AES Beginners Competition 2011 took place between 3rd and 4th of December 2011, in Ploiești, Romania. The event warmed debaters up for the upcoming academic year, full of debating competitions, but also challenged the participants in the audience to think about and discuss issues concerning civil rights and nuclear energy.
54 beginner debaters engaged in 4 rounds of debate, and the top teams advanced into the final debate, on the motion: “Nuclear energy is preferable to conventional sources of energy.”
The winning side was the Proposition, who managed to convince the judges that nuclear energy is both safer and more efficient than conventional sources of energy, making it a more profitable long-term investment. One of the most important points in the final debate that led to the judges’ decision was the safety argument. The proposition team proved that due to the recent scientific developments, accidents at nuclear power plants are very improbable. Also, they proved that even if such accidents would happen, the necessary technology and expertise to minimize its impact is in place, and further on discussed the recent Fukushima nuclear accident. Moreover, the Proposition team demonstrated that the radioactive toxic waste is nowadays well taken care of, being deposited in safe special containers, making it less dangerous than the CO2 emissions from the conventional power plants, or the disastrous oil spills. Regarding the radioactivity issue, the winning team brought into discussion a newly discovered chemical element – Thorium – which was proved to be an efficient replacement for Uranium, as it is many times less radioactive.
This event succeeded in opening a dialogue among the youth about important international issues while also providing them with the necessary tools to express their opinions. Furthermore, this project proved the local authorities that such events deserve their support in the future as well.
The other motion that was debated in 2 of the 4 rounds and in the semifinals was: “Citizens should have the right to bear arms.”
Apart from the direct impact on the participants, this event “energized” both partner high-schools and made them proud about their promising debaters. Also, the organizing team gained a lot of experience, and due to the feedback from the participants, they will be able to be more efficient and develop better and more creative projects in the future.
The competition was promoted on Facebook (http://www.facebook.com/pages/AES/163510330360709). In addition, a weekly show at a local TV channel (Alpha TV) invited the organizers to talk about the event. They discussed about the important skills that young people gain through debate and the “awakening” effect of such event on the local community, largely ignored in political debates, for example. A funny poster allured teens into joining the event and a debate club in their high school, thus making the first step, as “younglings” and then “apprentices” on the path that would lead them to the zenith of their debating career, where they would be Yoda Debaters : )